🔗 Share this article

As Esau Lopez was asphyxiated for the opening 17 minutes of his existence on the planet, the environment in the room remained serene, even euphoric. Soft music drifted from a sound system in a humble residence in a suburb of the state. “You are a queen,” whispered one of three friends in the room.

Just Esau’s mom, Gabrielle, perceived something was concerning. She was exerting herself, but her son would not be born. “Can you assist him?” she inquired, as Esau appeared. “Baby is arriving,” the companion replied. Four minutes later, Lopez repeated her question, “Can you take him?” Someone else said, “Baby is protected.” Several moments passed. Again, Lopez inquired, “Can you grab [him]?”

Lopez didn't notice the cord wrapped around her son’s throat, nor the foam emerging from his lips. She was unaware that his shoulder was grinding against her pubic bone, similar to a rubber rotating on rocks. But “deep down”, she states, “I knew he was lodged.”

Esau was experiencing shoulder dystocia, signifying his head was born, but his body did not follow. Childbirth specialists and doctors are educated in how to manage this issue, which happens in approximately 1% of births, but as Lopez was delivering without medical help, which means giving birth without any trained attendants present, not a single person in the area comprehended that, with each moment, Esau was experiencing an permanent neurological damage. In a birth overseen by a skilled practitioner, a five-minute interval between a baby’s head and body appearing would be an emergency. Such a lengthy delay is unthinkable.

Not a single person becomes part of a cult by choice. You think you’re joining a wonderful community

With a superhuman effort, Lopez bore down, and Esau was arrived at night on 9 October 2022. He was limp and floppy and lifeless. His body was pale and his lower body were discolored, evidence of lack of oxygen. The single utterance he emitted was a faint gurgle. His dad his father handed Esau to his mother. “Do you feel he requires oxygen?” she asked. “He’s fine,” her friend replied. Lopez held her motionless son, her gaze wide.

Everyone in the space was frightened now, but concealing it. To voice what they were all sensing seemed huge, similar to a violation of Lopez and her power to deliver Esau into the world, but also of something greater: of delivery itself. As the time passed slowly, and Esau didn’t stir, Lopez and her companions repeated of what their mentor, the creator of the natural birth group, this influencer, had told them: childbirth is natural. Have faith in nature.

So they controlled their rising panic and stayed. “It seemed,” recalls Lopez’s acquaintance, “that we entered some type of distorted perception.”

---

Lopez had met her three friends through the Free Birth Society (FBS), a company that champions unassisted childbirth. In contrast to home birth – birth at residence with a birth attendant in presence – natural delivery means having a baby without any medical support. The organization promotes a version generally viewed as radical, even among freebirth advocates: it is anti-ultrasound, which it falsely claims damages babies, minimizes serious medical conditions and promotes untracked gestation, meaning gestation without any prenatal care.

FBS was created by previous childbirth assistant this influencer, and the majority of females find it through its podcast, which has been downloaded five million times, its online presence, which has substantial audience, its video platform, with approximately twenty-five million views, or its bestselling comprehensive unassisted birth manual, a digital training jointly produced by this influencer with co-collaborator ex-doula Yolande Norris-Clark, accessible online from FBS’s slick website. Examination of their financial records by a specialist, a forensic accountant and researcher at the university, estimates it has generated revenues exceeding thirteen million dollars since that year.

After Lopez encountered the audio program she was hooked, following an program frequently. For this amount, she joined the organization's premium, private online community, the Lighthouse, where she connected with the three friends in the room when Esau was delivered. To plan for her unassisted childbirth, she purchased The Complete Guide to Freebirth in that spring for the price – a considerable expense to the then young childcare provider.

Subsequent to viewing numerous materials of organization resources, Lopez grew convinced freebirthing was the most secure way to deliver her unborn child, separate from unneeded treatments. Earlier in her extended delivery, Lopez had attended her nearby medical facility for an scan as the infant wasn’t moving as much as usual. Healthcare workers advised her to stay, cautioning she was at high risk of the birth issue, as the infant was “large”. But Lopez didn't worry. Fresh in her memory was a communication she’d received from the co-founder, stating anxieties of this complication were “overstated”. From this material, Lopez had understood that women’s “physiques will not develop babies that we are unable to deliver”.

Moments later, with Esau showing no respiratory effort, the trance in Lopez’s room broke. Lopez took charge, automatically providing emergency care on her baby as her {friend|companion|acquaint